User avatar
75evo
Verde
Verde
Posts: 944
Joined: Tue Oct 11, 2005 8:56 am

Re: LCA bolt failure?

Post by 75evo »

I think it's because Jim is trying to avoid major surgery so opening the chassis member is not an option.

Maybe he can partially strengthen the U by drilling at least 2 holes at then ends and weld a few strong stainless rods, the chassis member and U together. Minimum is 2 rods per U. The rods should be wide enough so that the pressure point isn't so concentrated

Not exactly ideal, but he can do this relatively quickly. I still think the U without a proper top to close the U is not so good, even with the rods.

Your solution is a lot better, but also requires a lot more effort.
Attachments
chassis_reinforcement.jpg
chassis_reinforcement.jpg (25.97 KiB) Viewed 4930 times
Jim K
Verde
Verde
Posts: 1751
Joined: Tue Nov 30, 2004 12:10 am
Location: Athens,Greece

Re: LCA bolt failure?

Post by Jim K »

I would definitely prefer to avoid surgery... Seeing how almost nobody else has had similar failures, I am more and more inclined to think its a fastener problem (saves me a bunch of trouble, too! 8) ). Alfa bolts are M12x1.25, 120mm long. However, they cannot be used as ~13mm more total length is needed to accommodate the longer conical LCA bases (now 27.5mm long for increased camber), 5mm for the stiffener and ~3 for the large washer. So, no 1.25 thread commercially available in length >120mm. Now this is important: The Alfa all-metal self-locking 1.25mm pitch nut used has 10mm of useful thread, while the nylon 1.75mm pitch self-lockers I used have <8mm, the rest being plastic. Again, since this failure seems to be very rare among a crowd using (and abusing) their cars in a similar way, this nut thing may be the star of everything! Cheap solution: Use grade 10.9 bolts, tighten with one std nut followed with a proper all-metal self-locker on top of that -all to increase clamping length. No configuration change, same stiffener placement. Drive the pi$$ out of it in our December trackday and re-inspect carefully immediately after that to check for possible thread damage in stiffener area. All in all, a lazyman's fix! :mrgreen: If it fails again... we'll get serious.
Titanium is a nice thought but I believe it's not stronger than steel when dimensions are the same -correct me if I'm wrong.
Jim K.
MR2 Zig
Verde
Verde
Posts: 766
Joined: Tue Jun 13, 2006 9:47 pm
Location: Fresno, Ca.
Contact:

Re: LCA bolt failure?

Post by MR2 Zig »

75,

Don't get too excited about using stainless on something like this. Welding stainless and carbon steel together can be done using the right electrode, but it isn't all that strong and takes a fair bit of heat to accomplish....difficult to do on stamped sheet metal.

JK,
If that "U" is welded all around over top of the frame rail it will act as a doubler and make that section of subframe much stiffer and give a good base for bolting in the cross piece. Drilling some holes in the "U" before installation and plug welding will help also.

That cross piece looks to be about as stiff as a wet noodle! :shock:

If I remember right, the stock arrangement had a lock washer under the nut.

Oh, almost forgot, use washers with the same strength rating as the bolts or they will deform under load.

hth,
Scott
MR1 Zig (I made rate!)
Machinery Repairman USNR
User avatar
75evo
Verde
Verde
Posts: 944
Joined: Tue Oct 11, 2005 8:56 am

Re: LCA bolt failure?

Post by 75evo »

All these talk about complex bracing, welding...in the end "hey I'll just buy new a new pair of nuts" :lol:

I think if the same bolts have been re-used with better nuts, that means it was the locking nuts that were defective. The threads stripped out.
User avatar
Maurizio
Verde
Verde
Posts: 680
Joined: Wed Dec 01, 2004 4:49 am
Location: the Netherlands, 153.1km from the N'ring :-)

Re: LCA bolt failure?

Post by Maurizio »

A lot of talk/solutions.
But no feel for the real forces generated with your brake upgrade....
Banned.. ? ;-) Daily donky.. ==> BMW 325d Image
E36M3 (3.0) Ringtool :twisted: ==> definitely BANNED!

AR 75 TS Ringtool '90, AR Spider 2000 veloce '79
Jim K
Verde
Verde
Posts: 1751
Joined: Tue Nov 30, 2004 12:10 am
Location: Athens,Greece

Re: LCA bolt failure?

Post by Jim K »

Let's see... Would a g-meter deceleration figure be good for you? I can hook up the G-Tech RR one of these days (after bolt/nut replacement) and do a few hard stops from ~160kph without tire lock.
Jim K.
Post Reply