Did I make a big mistake? Value of Carfax..
Posted: Thu Sep 06, 2007 4:12 pm
As you folks know, I recently introduced myself on the introduction page of this forum after buying a 1982 Alfa GTV-6 Balocco on Ebay. I paid $3,050.00 and I thought that was okay.
Here is the car I purchased for those of you unfamiliar:
http://tinyurl.com/2ncbs2
Then today, I saw this 1986 GTV-6 on Ebay with a buy it now price of $4,000 and thought "uh oh, I think me done somethin' stupid." Here is is:
http://tinyurl.com/yrusny
Since my Carfax subscription gives me unlimited searcges for a month, I decided to lok it up.
Lo and behold, it has some suspect data.
06/30/1992 59,704 California
Inspection Station
Perris, CA Passed emissions inspection
06/22/1994 81,905 California
Inspection Station
Maricopa, CA Passed emissions inspection
07/03/1996 California
Inspection Station
Maricopa, CA Passed emissions inspection
07/27/1999 California
Motor Vehicle Dept.
El Cajon, CA Title issued or updated
06/29/2002 69,718 California
Inspection Station
El Cajon, CA Failed emissions inspection
INCONSISTENT ODOMETER READING
07/05/2002 69,933 California
Inspection Station
El Cajon, CA Failed emissions inspection
07/09/2002 70,133 California
Inspection Station
San Diego, CA Passed emissions inspection
06/09/2004 91,531 California
Inspection Station
San Diego, CA Passed emissions inspection
04/20/2006 Georgia
Motor Vehicle Dept.
Moultrie, GA Vehicle purchase reported
04/20/2006 99,050 Georgia
Motor Vehicle Dept.
Moultrie, GA
Title #772854061104025 Title issued or updated
New owner reported
Vehicle color noted as Red
The seller says the odometer now reads at 17k+
As you can see there are some disturbing odometer reading issues here, open to all sorts of interpretations.
From '96 to '02 there were no emissions test, and given that in '99 the title was updated, something is going on during this period that is unsettling at some level perhaps.
The fact that between the last mileage reading in '94 - 81,905 - which was 22,200 miles more than the '92 reading (in itself a large number of miles in 2 years) and the next published reading in '02 - 69,718 - leads to all sorts of troubling questions about that six-year period, putting aside the large number of miles between '92 and '94 (it's more than average, anyway, I think we can agree on that).
This Carfax report would definitely prompt me to stay away from this GTV-6, which otherwise seems like a great deal, and at first glance I thought I made a really foolish decision when I bought the '82 (of course that remains to be seen, in any event), however my point here is that Carfax can really be an important tool in illuminating the past history, especially when the seller makes no mention of any irregularities (although he himself may be unaware in his defense).
If someone need a car run over the next few weeks let me know via e-mail, and I will run a report for you (I won't charge you too much either - smile).
Curious if anyone concurs or disagrees, in any event.
Thanks.
David B.
Here is the car I purchased for those of you unfamiliar:
http://tinyurl.com/2ncbs2
Then today, I saw this 1986 GTV-6 on Ebay with a buy it now price of $4,000 and thought "uh oh, I think me done somethin' stupid." Here is is:
http://tinyurl.com/yrusny
Since my Carfax subscription gives me unlimited searcges for a month, I decided to lok it up.
Lo and behold, it has some suspect data.
06/30/1992 59,704 California
Inspection Station
Perris, CA Passed emissions inspection
06/22/1994 81,905 California
Inspection Station
Maricopa, CA Passed emissions inspection
07/03/1996 California
Inspection Station
Maricopa, CA Passed emissions inspection
07/27/1999 California
Motor Vehicle Dept.
El Cajon, CA Title issued or updated
06/29/2002 69,718 California
Inspection Station
El Cajon, CA Failed emissions inspection
INCONSISTENT ODOMETER READING
07/05/2002 69,933 California
Inspection Station
El Cajon, CA Failed emissions inspection
07/09/2002 70,133 California
Inspection Station
San Diego, CA Passed emissions inspection
06/09/2004 91,531 California
Inspection Station
San Diego, CA Passed emissions inspection
04/20/2006 Georgia
Motor Vehicle Dept.
Moultrie, GA Vehicle purchase reported
04/20/2006 99,050 Georgia
Motor Vehicle Dept.
Moultrie, GA
Title #772854061104025 Title issued or updated
New owner reported
Vehicle color noted as Red
The seller says the odometer now reads at 17k+
As you can see there are some disturbing odometer reading issues here, open to all sorts of interpretations.
From '96 to '02 there were no emissions test, and given that in '99 the title was updated, something is going on during this period that is unsettling at some level perhaps.
The fact that between the last mileage reading in '94 - 81,905 - which was 22,200 miles more than the '92 reading (in itself a large number of miles in 2 years) and the next published reading in '02 - 69,718 - leads to all sorts of troubling questions about that six-year period, putting aside the large number of miles between '92 and '94 (it's more than average, anyway, I think we can agree on that).
This Carfax report would definitely prompt me to stay away from this GTV-6, which otherwise seems like a great deal, and at first glance I thought I made a really foolish decision when I bought the '82 (of course that remains to be seen, in any event), however my point here is that Carfax can really be an important tool in illuminating the past history, especially when the seller makes no mention of any irregularities (although he himself may be unaware in his defense).
If someone need a car run over the next few weeks let me know via e-mail, and I will run a report for you (I won't charge you too much either - smile).
Curious if anyone concurs or disagrees, in any event.
Thanks.
David B.